Frosty Frog Cafe

The Frosty Frog is a Coligny Beach institution — the kind of place that's been there forever and has no intention of changing, because why would it? The daiquiris are legendary. Not in a marketing way, in a 'people plan their beach day around stopping here' way. The frozen drink menu is extensive and dangerously easy to work through.

The food is exactly what you want after a morning at the beach — grouper tacos, pizza by the slice, solid burgers, and a menu that covers enough ground that everyone in the group finds something. It's not trying to be a fine dining destination. It's trying to be the best casual beach bar on the island, and it succeeds.

24 TVs mean sports are always on. Live music keeps the energy up. Outdoor seating means you can enjoy the Coligny vibe without being inside. Open late in season, which makes it a natural post-dinner stop too.