Tio's Latin American Kitchen

If you've been eating at the same seafood spots every trip and want something completely different, Tio's is where you go. It's a family-owned Latin American kitchen at Shelter Cove Towne Centre that pulls from Mexican, Cuban, and Central and South American traditions — and does it all really well. The tortillas are made fresh in-house every day, and once you taste them, you'll understand why people drive across the island specifically for the tacos.

The menu is bigger than you'd expect — burritos, quesadillas, enormous nachos, fajitas, and a whole section of bowls for the gluten-free crowd. The Tio's Steak Burrito with marinated ribeye and borracha sauce is the move if you're hungry. The Quesabirria Tacos (beef, melty cheese, onions, cilantro, consomé) are a newer addition and already a fan favorite. Happy hour runs daily and the margaritas are strong and well-priced.

The vibe is casual and colorful — there's a big Day of the Dead mural on the wall, string lights overhead, and the kind of energy that makes it feel like a neighborhood spot rather than a tourist trap. It's family-friendly, quick enough for a weeknight dinner, and fun enough for a group. Locals eat here regularly, which is about the best endorsement a restaurant on this island can get.